5 questions investors always ask – and what they actually mean

When I started pitching, I assumed every investor had their own script. In reality, they don’t. After enough meetings, you notice the same few questions come round again and again, just phrased slightly differently each time. 

Interestingly, they’re rarely asking what they appear to be asking. A slick, rehearsed answer isn’t the point. Each one is trying to get at something underneath that reflects your judgement, your honesty, whether you actually understand the business you’re building.

Here are the five questions I’ve been asked in almost every room, and what they’re really probing for.

1. “Why now?” On the surface, timing. Underneath, they’re asking whether you really understand the market window you’re building into. There’s always an external clock ticking along. My advice is this: don’t just say your idea is good. Explain why it couldn’t have worked five years ago, and why waiting five more would be too late.
2. “Why you?” The founder-market fit question. At the early stage they’re backing you far more than your spreadsheet. It’s about your motivation, your obsession, the reason you’ll still be here when things aren’t going entirely smoothly. The real story is always more convincing than the polished one you’re used to pitching.
3. “How unique is this, really?” This used to be a product question. In the age of AI it’s brutal, because “we built X” is no moat when a competitor can spin up something similar in a weekend. So, I wouldn’t base your defensibility on features that can be copied. The “unique” part of the product can also be you, your novel understanding of the problem, the network you’ve earned, and the insight you have.
4. “Where can this go?” This is the scalability question. They want to understand the ceiling, the size of what could be if everything goes right. This is your license to talk ambitiously, but it’s crucial to remember that ambition and fantasy are different things. An impressive, aspirational projection can appear unrealistic if the numbers propping it up don’t make sense.
5. “And how will you actually get there?” This is about execution, and the one founders most often fumble. Growing from 0 to 1 is a completely different sport from scaling 1 to 10. It requires different skills, risks, and more hiring. Being honest that you’re in the messy early innings, but clear-eyed about what comes next – and definitely don’t act like you’ve completely cracked scaling.

There’s actually a single, unifying question behind all of these explorative queries: “do I believe this person can build something big?” You answer it by being straight about what you know, honest about what you don’t, and clear about why you’re the right fit.

My frontline data this month

• 📊 Investor meetings taken: 11
• 🔁 “Why now?” asked, verbatim: 9
• 🧱 Times “moat” came up: too many to count
• ☕ Flat whites consumed pre-pitch: strictly one. Any more and the “why you?” answer gets very enthusiastic

Rita Kastrati - Founder of Pioneering People

Rita Kastrati grew up in and around the hospitality industry, where she watched restaurants and bars struggle with employee shortages. Then, at university, she worked shifts for agencies, and saw a broken system that sold staff short. Now, Rita's reshaping the gig economy on her own terms as the trailblazing Founder and CEO of Pioneering People, a platform that connects businesses with verified workers instantly, while ensuring workers are paid fairly and on the same day.

Pioneering People

This content is contributed by a guest author. Startups.co.uk / MVF does not endorse or take responsibility for any views, advice, analysis or claims made within this post.