Hospitality is first in line for a phased NI cut, but only “when fiscal conditions allow”. We asked experts what small venues should do now.
- The NI cut has no date: Milburn wants employer NI for 21 to 24-year-olds phased down over five years, starting with hospitality and retail, but only “when fiscal conditions allow”.
- Wages bite harder: Experts say a cut with no date won’t change hiring plans, and the real cost jump at 21 comes from higher wages, with NI on top.
- Hire well now: Look for attitude, train the managers who’ll look after new starters, and check whether you can claim the £3,000 Youth Jobs Grant
Alan Milburn’s final report on youth unemployment has good news for small hospitality businesses: cheaper young staff. The catch is that it comes “when fiscal conditions allow”.
The report proposes phasing down employer National Insurance (NI) for 21 to 24-year-olds over five years, with hospitality and retail going first and the threshold doubling from £5,000 to £10,000. Yet, with no firm date, most owners can’t plan a rota around it.
It also recommends a named adviser for every young person, a guaranteed paid job for anyone still not in education, employment or training (NEET) at 12 months, and expanded apprenticeships.
We asked hospitality and business experts what it means for small venues, and what owners can do now.
Milburn’s NEET report: What’s on the menu for small hospitality businesses?
Alan Milburn’s final report lands as many small venues are weighing up whether they can afford to take on young staff. For hospitality, the headline measure is the phased reduction in employer NI for 21 to 24-year-olds, with the sector among the first to benefit.
Hospitality expert Steven Hesketh, the founder of Savvy Collective, which runs several independent hotels, pubs, and social venues in Wrexham and Chester, says the biggest takeaway from the report is that tackling youth unemployment and supporting small hospitality businesses need to go hand in hand.
“Hospitality has always been an important entry point into employment for young people, offering practical skills, confidence, customer service experience and a route into long-term careers,” he told me, “but employers need to be able to afford to give people that first opportunity.”
Hesketh also welcomes the report’s named advisers and expanded apprenticeships, but says employers need help too. “Young people need guidance, but employers need better access to candidates, straightforward recruitment support and practical incentives to make hiring viable,” he explains. The timing of the NI cut was also a concern for several of the experts we spoke to.
Is “when fiscal conditions allow” good enough for small employers?
Hesketh calls the phased NI cut “a positive step”, particularly with hospitality among the first sectors to benefit. But he says the caveat that it will only happen “when fiscal conditions allow” is a concern.
“Small businesses need certainty when making recruitment decisions. If we are serious about encouraging employers to take on more young people, financial support needs to be tangible, predictable and available now, rather than being an aspiration for five years down the line,” he tells me.
Harvey Dhillon, founder and CEO of Zmartly, a UK accountancy firm used by hospitality businesses, agrees that a cut with no date won’t change hiring plans this winter.
“Owners budget on what’s law, not on ‘when fiscal conditions allow’,” he explains.
Dhillon says the real jump comes from wages, with NI on top. From April 2027, the National Living Wage for those aged 21 and over is £13.21 an hour, compared with £11.27 for 18 to 20-year-olds. Add 15% employer NI above £5,000 a year, and “the same person costs noticeably more the week after their birthday”.
Michael Steel, managing director of Southampton-based training provider Kiwi Education, says the government should go a step further. He argues that scrapping NI contributions for 18 to 24-year-olds altogether would be “one of the most impactful measures”.
“For many employers, especially SMEs, the cost of recruitment remains a significant barrier. Lowering those employment costs would make it easier for businesses to create entry-level roles, apprenticeships and structured training opportunities,” he says.
How can small venues get the most from a young hire?
The truth is, finding the right young recruit is only the first step. The hard work starts once they’re on the rota, and experts say what happens next decides whether they stay.
Hesketh’s advice to owners weighing up a young hire is to look beyond experience. “Look for attitude, enthusiasm and willingness to learn,” he says.
“Invest in people, give them proper training and a supportive environment, and you can develop loyal, capable team members while helping address a much bigger social challenge.”
– Steven Hesketh, CEO of SAVVY Collective
But training the new hire is only part of the picture. Ann Francke OBE, CEO of the Chartered Management Institute (CMI), the professional body for managers and leaders, says getting young people through the door is “only half the battle”.
“If we don’t train the managers who are charged with looking after them once they arrive, we won’t see benefits for either the young people or their employers,” she says.
The numbers back that up. According to Francke, research from the CMI found that only 6% of managers think young people have the skills to thrive at work, while 80% of young workers say a trained manager is critical to building their confidence.
James Reed CBE, chair and CEO of Reed, a recruitment firm that places hospitality and leisure staff, and president of the CMI, agrees that managers can make or break a first job.
“I’ve seen how a good manager can turn an inexperienced recruit into a confident, capable employee, while a poorly trained one can leave them struggling and out of work again within weeks,” he says.
The Milburn report offers small hospitality businesses the promise of cheaper young hires, but with no date attached, it’s one owners can’t yet budget around. With wage costs still rising, the best return comes from hiring well and backing the managers who look after new starters day to day. Here’s how to put that into practice, and a rundown of what support is available right now.
Support for young hires may not arrive for years, but some help already exists. Here’s how to make the most of it.
- Train the people who’ll manage young staff: Even a short course for your shift leads could be the difference between a hire who stays and one who leaves within weeks.
- Check the Youth Jobs Grant before you advertise: You could get up to £3,000 for hiring an 18 to 24-year-old who has been out of work and on Universal Credit for six months. The job must be at least 25 hours a week and last at least 16 weeks, and the money arrives in two stages.
- Use the NI relief that already exists: Employers pay no NI on an under-21’s wages up to £967 a week, and the same goes for apprentices under 25.
- Plan for the 21st birthday cost jump: From April 2027, the National Living Wage for over-21s is £13.21 an hour against £11.27 for 18 to 20-year-olds, with employer NI on top. We recommend building that into rotas and pricing now.